Some aluminum water bottles still contain BPA
Switching from reusable polycarbonate plastic water bottles to aluminum ones doesn’t necessarily prevent exposure to the hormone-disrupting chemical bisphenol-A (BPA). Thats according to a recent study examining whether materials used for BPA-free reusable bottles lived up to their claims.
The study, in the journal Chemosphere, found that some types of aluminum bottles are lined with an epoxy resin that leached even more BPA into water than did the plastic bottles that they were meant to replace. Epoxy resins also are commonly used to line food and beverage cans, and a Consumer Reports investigation found that almost all of the 19 name-brand canned foods we tested contained BPA, which some studies have linked to health effects including reproductive abnormalities and an increased risk of breast and prostate cancers, diabetes, and heart disease.
The water-bottle study, however, did have some good news. It found that some newer reusable water bottles did keep beverages free of BPA when used according to manufacturers recommendations. They were:
• Uncoated stainless steel bottles (brands tested were Sigg and Steel Works).
• Plastic bottles made of Tritan copolyester (brand tested was Nalgene)
• Aluminum bottles lined with EcoCare copolyester (brand tested was Sigg)
To assess manufacturers BPA-free claims, the researchers stored room-temperature BPA-free purified water in each type of bottle for five days and then tested that water. They found the highest BPA levels in water stored in epoxy-lined aluminum bottles branded New Balance that they purchased at Target, the national discount retail chain.
The concentration of BPA in those bottles was more than five times the concentration in polycarbonate plastic water bottles they tested under the same conditions. It also was 12 times higher than the amount of BPA they detected in water stored in unused older models of epoxy-lined aluminum bottles manufactured by Sigg before August 2008, when the company began making all of its aluminum bottles with a proprietary EcoCare lining, which the study found did live up to its BPA-free claim.
A separate set of tests conducted as part of the study also found that exposing polycarbonate or epoxy-lined bottles to heat significantly increases BPA leaching. When the scientists filled the epoxy-lined aluminum bottles with boiling water and then let that water cool and sit at room temperature, the migration of BPA into the water quadrupled.
While a copper or gold color in the lining of bottles can indicate an epoxy-resin coating, color alone isnt definitive, says Scott M. Belcher, Ph.D., an author of the study and professor of pharmacology and cell biophysics at the University of Cincinnati. For instance, epoxy linings in canned foods can be white or nearly transparent.
Similar Posts:
- Water Tank And Their Various Types
- Looking for an alternative to recalled Tylenol?
- More Tylenol recalled due to odor—and Lipitor, too
- Are Americans More Willing to Pay for Plastic Surgery Than Prescriptions?
- No need to avoid soy after breast cancer
